Over the last six months, I’ve noticed a major shift in my practice. More clients are coming to me after using ChatGPT or another AI tool to research their divorce, organize their thoughts, and sometimes even prepare legal arguments.

I don’t think that’s necessarily a bad thing. There are some things AI does remarkably well. But right now, I’m also seeing it create problems that didn’t exist a few years ago.

The biggest problem? People are starting to trust AI like it’s incapable of being wrong.

ChatGPT Sounds Convincing—Even When It’s Wrong

The tricky thing about ChatGPT is that a lot of what it tells you may be right. A lot of it may also be wrong. Unfortunately, both can sound equally convincing.

AI is exceptionally good at making you believe it knows what it’s talking about. You can ask a question about your divorce, get a detailed answer in seconds, and walk away feeling like you have a very strong legal position.

Not Every Argument Deserves Equal Weight

I’ve had clients come to me convinced they have a rock-solid argument because AI told them they did. Then I have to explain why the argument might technically make sense, but still isn't something I would recommend making in court.

You might have five possible arguments, and ChatGPT can make all five sound equally important. An experienced divorce lawyer may look at those same five and know that two matter, two probably won't help, and the fifth could actually make you look petty in front of a judge.

AI Tells You What You Want to Hear

Another problem is that AI is working with the information you give it. If you explain why you think something is unfair and ask it to build an argument around that, it can usually give you a pretty convincing one.

I’m on my client's side too. But part of my job is telling you what you need to hear, even when it isn't necessarily what you want to hear.

How I Would Actually Use ChatGPT During a Divorce

With all of that said, if I were getting divorced, I would use ChatGPT. I just wouldn't use it as my lawyer.

AI can be very good at taking a large amount of information and organizing it. It can also help put something you're struggling to explain into clearer words.

I’d Use It to Help Tell My Story

Clients often come into my office trying to explain years of financial decisions, parenting issues, conversations, and important events. Naturally, that story isn't always going to come out in perfect chronological order.

This is where I think AI can be genuinely helpful.

Turn Years of Information Into Something Useful

I might give ChatGPT my notes and ask it to organize the events chronologically, highlight important dates, and condense everything into a one- or two-page summary. I could then review it for accuracy before giving it to my attorney.

Now I’m not asking AI to decide my case. I’m asking it to help me tell my story.

That means my attorney can spend less time piecing together the basic timeline and more time talking to me about what actually matters.

I’d Use It to Compare and Organize Information

AI can also be helpful when you're dealing with a lot of information. It can compare two versions of a document and help identify what changed, or turn scattered notes into something easier to review.

You can also use it to organize your questions before meeting with your attorney. When you're paying an attorney by the hour, walking into that meeting organized can make that time much more productive.

I Wouldn't Have ChatGPT Write My Legal Argument

This is where I’ve seen AI go from being helpful to creating significantly more work.

I’ve had clients tell me, “I’ve already written the brief for you.” Then I open the document and find 20-plus single-spaced pages.

More Information Doesn't Mean a Better Argument

The client thinks they’ve handed me a crib sheet. In reality, they’ve handed me a novel that I now have to read, fact-check, cut down, and turn into something I can actually use.

When I put something in front of a judge, I’m responsible for what is in it. If AI invents a case, misstates the law, or gives me something that doesn't apply, I can't simply pass it along because it sounds convincing.

Give AI Parameters

I have to go through those documents with a fine-tooth comb, and sometimes that takes longer than preparing the argument correctly from the beginning.

If you use AI to prepare something for your attorney, give it parameters. Ask for a one-page summary instead of 20 pages. Tell it to organize your facts rather than make legal conclusions.

The goal should be to give your attorney something useful, not simply more information to sort through.

Don't Have a Lawyer? AI Can Still Be Helpful

I can see real value in ChatGPT for someone who is representing themselves. It can help organize your story, compare documents, improve your writing, or prepare something to send to opposing counsel.

But without an attorney there to catch mistakes, you need to be especially careful about what you trust.

One AI Mistake Can Become a Credibility Problem

AI can give you a case citation or quotation that looks completely legitimate and is completely wrong.

If you put that information in front of a judge without checking it, you risk damaging your credibility. Once a judge starts questioning whether the information you're providing is reliable, you have created a much bigger problem.

Use It as a Tool, Not an Authority

If ChatGPT gives you legal information, find the original source and verify it yourself. Don't assume something is accurate simply because it sounds accurate.

AI can be an incredibly useful tool when it's used for the right things. But it still can't replace the judgment, critical thinking, and human interaction that a divorce case requires.

My advice to clients is pretty simple:

Use ChatGPT to tell your story. Don’t use it to argue your case.